Do you need a mattress topper? Pros, Cons and How to Decide - Tontine
Search My Tontine

Do You Need a Mattress Topper?

We all know that a good night's sleep is essential for our overall health and wellbeing. An oft-overlooked aspect of getting a restful sleep is the quality of your mattress. If you're dissatisfied with your current mattress, hold your horses before you decide to replace it completely - you might just need a mattress topper. In this article, we'll explore the pros and cons of using a mattress topper to help you decide whether it's a worthwhile addition to your sleep setup.

What does a mattress topper do?

Firstly, you might be wondering what a mattress topper actually does. Well, wonder no more - let’s do a deep dive into the benefits!

Enhanced Comfort

One of the primary benefits of using a mattress topper is the added comfort it provides. Toppers come in various materials like memory foam, latex, and down, which can provide extra cushioning and support. If your mattress is too firm, a soft topper can make it feel more comfortable, and if your mattress is too soft, a firmer topper will add the necessary support.

If this is a problem you face, the Tontine Soft & Snuggly Mattress Topper might be just what you’re after.

Pressure Relief

If you suffer from sore joints and body aches, mattress toppers can help to alleviate pressure points and make it easier to sleep soundly throughout the night. Memory foam and latex toppers are particularly good at conforming to your body's shape, which can reduce the stress on your joints and muscles. Check out our Pressure Relieving Memory Foam Mattress Topper that helps disperse your body weight more evenly.

Improved Temperature Regulation

Some mattress toppers, like gel-infused memory foam, are designed to regulate temperature, keeping you cool during hot nights. This can be a game-changer in the Aussie summer if you often find yourself overheating! Shop thermoregulating mattress toppers.


Buying a mattress topper is generally more budget-friendly than purchasing an entirely new mattress. This makes it a cost-effective option for those looking to improve their sleep quality without breaking the bank.

Easy To Clean

Mattress toppers are relatively easy to maintain, and are definitely much easier than cleaning a mattress! Most toppers are machine washable, and by acting as a barrier between your body and your mattress, they protect your mattress from any stains and spills.


Mattress toppers are available in various thicknesses and materials, allowing you to customise your sleep surface to meet your specific needs. This can be especially beneficial for couples who have different sleep preferences.

Prolonging Mattress Lifespan

If your mattress is still in decent condition but has lost some of its comfort and support over time, a topper can help extend its lifespan. Moreover, as a protective layer it can help maintain your mattress from wear and tear over time, saving you money in the long run.

Are there any downsides of a mattress topper?

Not a Permanent Fix

While mattress toppers can improve the comfort and support of your mattress, they are not a long-term solution if your mattress is severely damaged or old. If your mattress has sagging areas or structural issues, a topper won't fix these problems.

Potential Allergies

Depending on the material, some mattress toppers can exacerbate allergies. For example, down-filled toppers might trigger dust allergies in some individuals. It's important to choose a hypoallergenic or synthetic topper if you know you are susceptible to allergies or sensitivities.

Unideal Thickness

The thickness of the mattress topper matters. If you select a topper that is too thick for your mattress, it can make your bed feel lumpy and uneven. What’s more, it may also mean your existing sheets will no longer fit, and you may have to make the switch to extra deep fitted sheets. Conversely, if it's too thin, you may not get the desired level of comfort and support.

Underlays are typically thinner than a mattress topper, and could be a good option if you’re just after a little extra comfort. Check out our underlay buying guide.

Cleaning Challenges

While many toppers are machine washable, not all are, and cleaning a thicker or heavier topper (think one that doesn’t fold) can be challenging. Make sure to choose a topper (or protector) that fits your maintenance preferences.

Our Easy Care Mattress Protector is soft, durable, and super easy to look after.


Mattress toppers may not last as long as a high-quality mattress, which can last for up to 25 years. Their lifespan can vary based on the material of their filling and casing, and how well they are cared for. If you choose a lower-quality topper, you might find yourself needing to replace it sooner than you'd like.

What Should I Consider Before Getting a Mattress Topper?

If you’re still on the fence about whether you need a mattress topper or would be better off taking the plunge for a new mattress, run through the following checklist:

Your Current Mattress Condition

Evaluate the condition of your current mattress. If it's relatively new and still in good shape, a topper might be all you need to enhance your sleep quality. However, if your mattress is old and sagging, it's advisable to invest in a new mattress for long-term comfort and support.

Sleep Preferences

Consider your sleep preferences. Do you prefer a firmer or softer sleeping surface? What’s your favourite sleeping position? Your preference will influence the type of mattress topper you should choose.


Determine how much you're willing to spend. While mattress toppers are generally more affordable than mattresses, there's still a range of prices depending on the material and quality. Set a budget and stick to it.

Material Selection

Each type of mattress topper material has its own unique qualities. Memory foam is great for pressure relief, while latex offers durability and natural materials. Be sure to research and choose the material that suits your needs. For general information on material, take a look at our Mattress Topper Buying Guide.


Think about how easy it is to clean and maintain the topper. This can be especially important if you have allergies, pets, kids, or health issues which necessitate regular cleaning of your bedding.


Pay attention to the thickness of the topper. It should complement your mattress, not overwhelm it or make it too thin. Remember, you don’t want an unwanted surprise of having to replace all your fitted sheets if you can avoid it!

In conclusion, whether or not you need a mattress topper depends on your individual circumstances and preferences. If you have a relatively new and comfortable mattress but want to enhance its feel, a topper could be an excellent choice.

However, if your mattress is in poor condition, a topper won't solve structural issues and you may be better off investing in a new mattress sooner rather than later. Ultimately, your choice should be based on what will provide you with the best sleep experience, considering your comfort, support, and overall wellbeing.

For more information, check out our mattress topper buying guide or shop mattress toppers today.